Scripture
Today's Chapters: Genesis
36-38
Today's
Key
Verses: 24About
three
months later Judah was told, "Tamar your daughter-in-law has been
immoral. Moreover, she is pregnant by immorality." And Judah said,
"Bring her out, and let her be burned."
(Genesis
38:25
ESV)
Observation
In the middle of the Old Testament story of Joseph, while Jacob is
mourning (what he believed to be) the loss of his son Joseph, another
son, Judah, separated himself from the family group and took up with a
Canaanite friend, Hirah the Adullamite (Genesis
38:1). Judah, like
Reuben, had previously shown a fair amount of independence during the
fraternal negotiations over how to get rid of Joseph, and had suggested
that they sell their youngest brother rather than kill him (Genesis
37:27). In Chapter 38, though, he took this independence to the
next level. Judah left his brothers to join up with
Hirah, and then made matters worse by marrying a Canaanite woman. By
the
time she died, Judah was steeped in the Canaanite culture, and decided
to join the raucous sheep-shearing revelries with his friend Hirah. In
the spirit of the festivities, he saw no problem propositioning a woman
who might or might not have been a shrine prostitute. He assumed that
she was a prostitute because she covered her face, but as Joan Goodnick
Westenholz points out in a
carefully
researched article in The
Harvard Theological Review, this was presumptuous on the
part of
Judah. And he was not dissuaded by the fact that if she was a
prostitute, she would have been connected to the pagan religious
practices of the Canaanites. In any event, after Tamar later was
discovered to be pregnant, Judah
attempted to solve two problems (the embarrassment of a pregnant
daughter-in-law, and the ongoing dilemma of his duty to have is
youngest son father a child by her) with one solution. He attempted to
kill two birds, but not with one stone. He ordered her to be burned
rather than stoned. Again, this reflected a closer connection to the
Canaanite culture (where life was less sacred and where burning a
convicted woman was more common) than his Hebrew culture (where the
Mosaic law would eventually call for the stoning of adulterers - Deuteronomy 22:20-24 - and
would reserve burning as the capital punishment in only a few specific
circumstances - Leviticus 20:14; 21:9).
Even prior to the Mosaic law, Judah had adopted a
lifestyle that involved more permission to behave in sinful ways than
the manner of living in which he had been raised by his parents. When
he realized that he was the father of Tamar's baby (as a result of his
own immorality), he was overcome by the realization that he, not Tamar,
was deserving of the most severe punishment.
Application
It is commonly believed that cultural relativism (the idea that
different cultures have different mores or customs) entails moral
relativism. In other words, it is often presumed that just because a
culture permits a behavior, that behavior is necessarily morally
acceptable and right. Various cultures at various times and places have
adopted a wide range of deviant practices, from infanticide to
pederasty to cannibalism to the severe oppression and humiliation of
women ... to any number of sexual and social practices. This can be
appealing, and can work well for folks who prefer to "shop" cultures
and sub-cultures in order to find and adopt cultural mores that suit
their fancy. And it worked well for Judah, to the extent that Judah
abandoned the mores of Jacob (and the God of Jacob) and took up the
ways of the Canaanites. By God's grace, Tamar brought Judah face to
face with his own depravity, and in his epiphany of remorse he
repented. He suddenly realized that the lifestyle he had permitted
himself was in complete opposition to the character and the holiness --
and the law -- of God.
Prayer
Father forgive me ... in Jesus name. Amen.
